Try this deliciously amazing Caramelized Mushroom and Onion Melt Sandwich by Dax Phillips of SimpleComfortFood.com


Created by:  on April 4th, 2013 Sourced from www.simplecomfortfood.com

I know there is all this hype around ‘Grilled Cheese Sandwich Month’ going on right now, and I love that people get excited about that. Don’t get me wrong, I am in favor of awesome grilled cheese sandwiches, and I believe melts are right up there with the grilled cheese, heck, they should be in the same category as the grilled cheese, right?  You might have seen recipes of mine such as the Monte Cristo, theBeef and Cheddar Melt, the Korean Grilled Cheese, the Perfect Grilled Cheese, or heck, even the Shrimp Rangoon Grilled Cheese. As you can see, I love grilled cheese sandwiches, and that is why I am pleased to provide you a recipe for my recent creation, the caramelized mushroom and onion melt. This sandwich is a thing of beauty.




  • 2 Stecca’s, or your favorite rustic sandwich bread, sliced in half, lengthwise
  • 3 tbsp unsalted butter
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 1 pinch of cracked black pepper
  • 16 oz cremini mushrooms, stems removed, cleaned, and quartered
  • 2 small onions, halved, thinly sliced
  • 1 whole jalapeno pepper, seeds removed, thinly sliced
  • 1/2 tbsp fresh rosemary, finely minced
  • 4 slices baby swiss cheese
  • 4 slices harvarti cheese
  • 2 tbsp mayonnaise
  • Fresh greens, lightly tossed in olive oil, optional


Start by getting a large, nonstick skillet on medium heat. Toss in the mushrooms, onions, jalapeno, and rosemary. Season with salt and pepper, and add in one tablespoon of the butter. Let this just cooke for a couple of minutes, then give it a good flip, or stir, whatever you are comfortable with. Lower the heat a bit, and continue to cook for about 20 minutes, stirring or flipping along the way. Your goal is to bring out those natural sugars and caramelize the mushrooms, and onions. The mixture will reduce in size as well. Once caramelized, set it aside.


Take the remaining butter and lightly butter all four slices of the bread. My skillet only holds two slices, so I laid them butter side down in a large, nonstick skillet on medium heat. Cook them until they are nice and toasted. Repeat with the remaining two slices.

Preheat your oven to 325 degrees.


Once toasted, lather the bottom stecca, or one slice of each bread with mayonnaise. Cover with two slices of swiss cheese, then top with the caramelized mushroom mixture. Top that with the two slices of harvarti cheese, then top with the other slice of bread.


Repeat with the other sandwich.


Place these onto a baking sheet and place into the oven for about 5-7 minutes, or until the cheese is nice and melted.


To plate, slice in half on the diagonal, and serve with a nice green salad.


Biting into this sandwich is freaking delicious. You get that wonderful earthiness from the caramelized mushrooms and the sweetness from the onions. Then boom, you get that flavor from the rosemary as a nice surprise. This was everything I was looking for when I came up with the idea, and that bread, well, don’t even get me started on that. Those steccas are not only super easy to make, but probably the best sandwich bread I have had, and that’s no lie.







More Articles

Schreiner's 01

THIS WEEK ON FOODIE: Schreiner’s Restaurant & Bay View Packing Company

On the season finale of Wisconsin Foodie, we visit Schreiner’s Restaurant, Bay View Packing company, and close it out with Wolski’s.

by: Arthur Ircink

Deer Butchery 01


It’s deer season this week on Wisconsin Foodie! Keith Warnke from the Department of Natural Resources guides us as well as Kyle through the Wisconsin tradition of hunting.

by: Arthur Ircink


THIS WEEK ON FOODIE: Roelli Cheese & Driftless Café

This week, we eat some of Roelli Cheese’s award winning cheese and make some incredible dishes with it at Driftless Café.

by: Arthur Ircink


THIS WEEK ON FOODIE : Amaranth Bakery & Madison Sourdough Company

This week, we load on the carbs with Amaranth Bakery and Madison Sourdough Company.

by: Arthur Ircink

Screen Shot 2015-02-23 at 12.13.25 PM


This week, we’re going fishing at Rushing Waters Trout Farm!

by: Arthur Ircink

Screen Shot 2015-02-16 at 1.25.36 PM

THIS WEEK ON FOODIE: Apple Sauced | Weston’s Antique Apples | New Glarus Fruit Caves

We are all things apple this week on Wisconsin Foodie! We check out Edible Milwaukee’s Apple Sauced Event, Weston’s Antique Apple Orchard, and New Glarus Brewery’s new fruit caves.

by: Arthur Ircink

Screen shot 2015-02-09 at 3.54.13 PM


We celebrate the 100th anniversary of Cheese Days in Monroe, Wi!

by: Arthur Ircink

Screen shot 2015-02-03 at 4.48.11 PM

THIS WEEK ON FOODIE: Fondy Farm Feast & Dinner Service

We dine at two farm dinners! First, the Fondy Farm Feast and then at Dinner Service!

by: Arthur Ircink

Screen shot 2015-01-26 at 12.16.59 PM

THIS WEEK ON FOODIE: Door County Creamery & Door County Brewery

This week we return to Door County to check out Door County Creamery and Door County Brewery.

by: Arthur Ircink

Screen shot 2015-01-19 at 2.57.51 PM

THIS WEEK ON FOODIE: The Victory Garden Initiative

This week on Wisconsin Foodie, we help Gretchen Mead install gardens in people’s as part of the Victory Garden Initiative. Then we come back to see how Concordia Gardens has grown over the season.

by: Arthur Ircink

WMMB - Rotational AD
Outpost Natural Foods Co-op v2
Our Media Partners

Copyright © 2012 Wisconsin Foodie. All rights reserved.

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Wisconsin Foodie